Fintech

Africa's Instant Payment Systems: Why They Stagnate at the Basics

The central problem is not technology, but governance. Non-bank payment providers often have limited network access and little influence over pricing.…

Africa's Instant Payment Systems: Why They Stagnate at the Basics

The Governance Gap

The central problem is not technology, but governance. Non-bank payment providers often have limited network access and little influence over pricing. They lack clear channels to contest decisions made by system operators.

Breaking news

Italy Accelerates Digital Euro Rollout With Major Payments FirmsItaly Accelerates Digital Euro Rollout With Major Payments FirmsItaly Moves Ahead With Digital Euro InfrastructureItaly Moves Ahead With Digital Euro InfrastructureA Week of Digital Instability Highlights Fragile InfrastructureA Week of Digital Instability Highlights Fragile InfrastructureAdyen integrates Klarna into its agentic commerce payment suiteAdyen integrates Klarna into its agentic commerce payment suite

Kenya's PesaLink exemplifies this tension. Technically, it is near progresslevel, but governance holds it back. The network is run by Integrated Payment Services Limited (IPSL), owned solely by the Kenya Bankers Association (KBA). Non-bank participants have no representation in KBA's decision-making.

The Kenya Case: PesaLink and the Fight for Fair Pricing

Gituku Kirika, IPSL's CEO, explained that the network aims to make bank transfers cheaper through a common fee structure. This structure offers free transfers up to 1,000 KES (approx. $7.75) and charges 20 KES ($0.15) for larger amounts. Sending 50,000 KES ($388) costs only 20 KES under this fee, compared to 108 KES ($0.84) on M-PESA or Airtel Money.

Five major Kenyan banks—KCB, Co-operative Bank, NCBA, Absa, and Stanbic—have already adopted this model. However, Equity Bank, Standard Chartered, and I&M have not aligned yet. We do not impose prices on our customers, but we share what we believe is the right approach to instant payment pricing. Banks make decisions based on their strategies and budgets, Kirika said. He expects all banks to align by the end of 2027, but IPSL lacks the power to force them.

A similar situation exists in Mozambique, where the national switch SIMOrede suffers the same governance issues. Digital money issuers face board decisions without voting rights. Although non-bank PesaLink members—credit cooperatives (SACCOs), fintechs, mobile operators, and microfinance banks—outnumber the banks, they lack voting rights.

The Growth Paradox: More Users, Less Revenue

The 11 systems classified as in progresshave passed the governance test but fail the economic sustainability test. None allow credit or insurance products on the network. Some offer consumer protection no better than regulatory minimums. Fixing these gaps costs money, and these systems have fewer resources year after year.

Data shows a clear trend: between 2021 and 2025, transaction volume on African systems grew 28% annually, but value grew only 11%. The average payment value dropped from $43 in 2022 to $26 in 2025. On mobile money systems, the average is now just $9. This decline indicates more people are using these systems for daily spending, which is their intended purpose.

However, for operators, it is a business where each sale becomes smaller, but processing costs do not drop. A switch fulfilling its mission earns less per transaction. The next maturity level requires building dispute resolution offices and anti-fraud systems, which they can barely afford.

The Importance of Consumer Redress

The report suggests operators should stop relying solely on per-transaction commissions and start selling additional services. Banks could pay for credit tools, anonymized data, or shared intelligence in the fight against fraud. While economically sensible, this transition is difficult, like asking a utility company to start managing a restaurant. Most of these systems were designed as public utilities: excellent at being boring, but weak at sales.

Consumer redress deserves investment. AfricaNenda surveyed 1,403 people across 15 markets about their digital payment experiences. Between one-third and one-half were victims of fraud or encountered failed transactions.

More stories:

Share:

Leave a comment

Comments are moderated. It will be displayed as soon as it is approved. You can send at most 2 comments per hour.